DON’T MISS
IamExpat FairIamExpat Job BoardIamExpat Webinars
Newsletters
EXPAT INFO
CAREER
HOUSING
EDUCATION
LIFESTYLE
EXPAT SERVICES
NEWS & ARTICLES
Home
Lifestyle
Dutch news & articles
Dutch judge uses ChatGPT as information source for verdict
Never miss a thing!Sign up for our weekly newsletters with important news stories, expat events and special offers.
Keep me updated with exclusive offers from partner companies
By signing up, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our privacy policy

Dutch judge uses ChatGPT as information source for verdict

Never miss a thing!Sign up for our weekly newsletters with important news stories, expat events and special offers.
Keep me updated with exclusive offers from partner companies
By signing up, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our privacy policy
or
follow us for regular updates:



Related Stories

These are the most common passwords used in the Netherlands for 2024These are the most common passwords used in the Netherlands for 2024
Meta to use European users’ data for AI: How Dutch users can opt outMeta to use European users’ data for AI: How Dutch users can opt out
This Dutch website helps find sunny terraces near youThis Dutch website helps find sunny terraces near you
8 best food delivery apps in the Netherlands8 best food delivery apps in the Netherlands
Influencers & bloggers in the NetherlandsInfluencers & bloggers in the Netherlands
July 2025: 12 things expats in the Netherlands need to knowJuly 2025: 12 things expats in the Netherlands need to know
Official Dutch guidelines set minimum age for social media at 15Official Dutch guidelines set minimum age for social media at 15
Amsterdam launches shade project with movable greenery to combat summer heatAmsterdam launches shade project with movable greenery to combat summer heat
For expats of all colours, shapes and sizes

Explore
Expat infoCareerHousingEducationLifestyleExpat servicesNews & articles
About us
IamExpat MediaAdvertisePost a jobContact usSitemap
More IamExpat
IamExpat Job BoardIamExpat HousingIamExpat FairsWebinarsNewsletters
Privacy
Terms of usePrivacy policyCookiesAvoiding scams

Never miss a thing!Sign up for expat events, news & offers, delivered once a week.
Keep me updated with exclusive offers from partner companies
By signing up, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our privacy policy


© 2025 IamExpat Media B.V.
© 2025 IamExpat Media B.V.
Aug 7, 2024
Simone Jacobs

Editor at IamExpat Media

Editor for the Netherlands at IamExpat Media. Simone studied Genetics and Zoology at the University of Pretoria in South Africa before moving to the Netherlands, where she has been working as a writer and editor since 2022. One thing she loves more than creating content is consuming it, mainly by reading books by the dozen. Other than being a book dragon, she is also a nature lover and enjoys hiking and animal training. Read more

For the first time in the Netherlands, a judge in Nijmegen has used ChatGPT as an information source to come to a verdict on compensation in a legal dispute between two homeowners. Many experts in the fields of AI and law are questioning whether this was responsible.

Dutch judge uses AI to determine compensation in court case

The case in question concerns two homeowners in Gelderland who got into a disagreement over compensation. One had done some home renovations to add a floor to his house, while the other homeowner wanted compensation for the decreased efficiency of their solar panels due to the neighbour’s house overshadowing them. 

The district judge used ChatGPT as an information source for the average life span of solar panels and the current average price of electricity. ChatGPT is even mentioned in the court ruling: “The judge estimates, partly on the basis of ChatGPT, that that the average life span of a solar panel from 2009 to be between 25 and 30 years, so for this case we have put it at 27.5 years.”

Using this information, the judge determined how much the loss of efficiency would cost the claimant.  

Experts sceptical about use of AI in judiciary

AI Expert Henk van Ess finds the use of ChatGPT in a court case “ridiculous”. “You have to take every AI bot with a pinch of salt,” he told AD. The case itself is also complicated as experts on solar panels are still divided about the lifespan of the technology, with varying opinions of 25 years to 40 years.

According to tech experts, AI on the internet can be useful as a tool, but answers from the language model should be checked thoroughly. “ChatGPT has no knowledge. It is not a database,” said another AI expert Jarno Duursma. “It is a computer system that guesses the next word in a sentence, nothing more.” 

A spokesperson for the Gelderland District Court has said that the judge only used ChatGPT as one source of information, among others, and that “this data was not the deciding factor in dismissing the case".

By Simone Jacobs