close

Controversial petition calls for compulsory contraception for 'unfit mothers'

Controversial petition calls for compulsory contraception for 'unfit mothers'

Controversial petition calls for compulsory contraception for 'unfit mothers'

A group of experts have submitted a controversial petition to the House of Representatives (Tweede Kamer), calling for women who are deemed unsuitable for parenthood due to addiction, mental health, or mental disability to receive a mandatory injection or contraceptive implant to prevent pregnancy

Mandatory contraception for unfit mothers in the Netherlands

The group - known as the Standing Committee on Compulsory Contraception - was founded by Cees de Groot, former juvenile court judge and former vice president of the district court in Rotterdam. The proposed law has the support of a number of experts, including retired professor of medical ethics and former cabinet minister, Heleen Dupuis, and former professor of adoption, René Hoksbergen.

The petition aims to give Child Protective Services and the Public Prosecution Service the power to request the court to impose mandatory (temporary) contraception on someone who is deemed unprepared or unsuitable for parenthood.

Could apply to hundreds of women across the Netherlands

According to the proposal, this power would be used in cases involving individuals who suffer from an addiction, hepatitis B or C or HIV, psychiatric illnesses, mental disabilities, or histories of child abuse - and thus, the experts argue, pose a potential risk to any future child - but refuse to accept contraception and consequently risk becoming pregnant. 

Those in support of the proposed law have cited examples in which it could be used, and members of the expert group state there are hundreds of vulnerable women across the Netherlands who could benefit from the proposed legislation. Dupuis said that when she worked as chair of the Association for Disabled Care in the Netherlands (VGN) she met a number of women who were proven to be unable to raise a child, but still wanted to become pregnant - in her opinion, this law would therefore be the lesser of two evils.

Dutch MP's hesitant to support the proposal

The proposal is exceedingly controversial, especially considering that current legislation gives practically everyone the basic right to reproduce freely. Members of parliament are reluctant to support the proposal. 

Ockje Tellegen, member of the People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD) said: “Children must be protected, sometimes unfortunately also from their parents. They cannot do that themselves, so there is a task for the government. Doctors and judges can already advise contraception. The question is therefore whether a separate law is necessary. The VVD is very hesitant.”

Member of the Reformed Political Party (SGP), Kees van der Staaij, acknowledged it was a complicated topic, but said: “As far as [SGP] are concerned, the government should never cross the border to determine who can have children.”

Victoria Séveno

Author

Victoria Séveno

Victoria grew up in Amsterdam, before moving to the UK to study English and Related Literature at the University of York and completing her NCTJ course at the Press Association...

Read more

JOIN THE CONVERSATION (3)

COMMENTS

Leave a comment

MilenaBuso2 22:24 | 28 October 2020

And about the men with the same problems? Are we in an equal country or not?

MichelleKhan2 11:11 | 29 October 2020

What an unnecessary and disgraceful article to add to this website! Really appalling and shameful. I'm disgusted to say the least!

MichelleKhan2 11:57 | 29 October 2020

You have thousands of children being abused by the system in England. Which is actually involving those persons meaning to protect them! Doctors, healthcare workers, teachers etc. And how would persons ascertain a person is worthy of being a parent? I've seen multiple persons not worthy. But, you cannot take away their basic human right. Even mental impaired persons have that right, and could probably be better parents than most!